Critter Culture
Fun and Safe Handmade Toy Ideas for Cats

Fun and Safe Handmade Toy Ideas for Cats

Critter Culture Staff



Cats are curious by nature, thriving on play and exploration to keep their minds sharp and bodies agile. Crafting handmade toys for your feline friend isn’t just a way to save money; it’s a pathway to bonding, offering personalized fun that store-bought toys simply can’t match. Plus, repurposing household items into cat toys is a nod towards sustainability, turning potential waste into hours of entertainment. From simple crafts to interactive puzzles, the following ideas will ensure your cat is engaged, safe, and thoroughly entertained.


Recycled magic with toilet rolls

Closeup of a red cat and a grey mouse made of toilet paper roll by a child

Who knew that a toilet paper roll could provide so much fun? Flatten them, cut them into rings, and interlock them to create a ball, or hide treats inside for a tasty puzzle. They're perfect for batting around or tearing apart, satisfying your cat's predatory instincts without breaking the bank. This simple idea not only recycles but also taps into the joy cats find in the most ordinary objects, turning them into extraordinary playthings.


The allure of catnip yarn balls

Kuril Bobtail cat plays with a ball of gray thread. Thoroughbred cat. Cute and funny kitten. Pet. Soft focus

Combine the irresistible allure of catnip with the tactile pleasure of yarn to create a toy that’s bound to be a hit. Wrap yarn around a small, catnip-stuffed fabric ball, securing it tightly so it doesn’t unravel during play. These homemade yarn balls are not just fun to chase; they’re also safe for your cat to nibble on. The scent of catnip stimulates your cat's senses, making these yarn balls an addictive toy they won't be able to resist.


Feathered friends for feline fun

Cute Scottish Kitten Playing Toy On Wood Table

Mimic the thrill of the hunt with homemade feather toys. Attach feathers to a string and secure them to a stick; you’ve got a simple, effective toy that encourages natural hunting behaviors. Watching your cat leap and dance after these feathered friends isn’t just entertaining—it’s a great way for them to exercise. The movement of the feathers ignites their hunting instincts, providing a healthy outlet for their energy.


Interactive cardboard games

A little kitten plays with an interactive handmade toy. Cardboard box with holes with cat toys inside. Sorter.

Turn a simple cardboard box into an arcade-style game. Cut holes and hide toys or treats inside, creating a puzzle that challenges your cat mentally and physically. It’s a fantastic way to repurpose boxes, ensuring they're entertained for hours trying to solve the mystery of what’s inside. These games tap into their curiosity and problem-solving skills, making each play session both stimulating and rewarding.


Sock toys: soft and safe

Siberian kitten playing with socks. Puppy cat, hypoallergenic cat. Long-haired cat.

Old socks can find new life as cat toys. Fill them with catnip, sew them shut, and watch your cat go wild. For added excitement, tie a string around the sock; it becomes a prey they can hunt and capture. Soft and safe, these toys are perfect for cats who love to cuddle or kick. The familiar scent of the sock may also comfort them, making these toys a favorite for both play and nap times.


Building a cardboard cat palace

Кitten peeking out of white cardboard box with decorative hole. Cat banner, copy space, selective focus

With some cardboard boxes, you can construct a cat palace, fort, or maze. It’s an architect’s dream, limited only by your imagination. Cats love exploring these homemade structures, and they provide a sense of security and a space to retreat, ensuring they’re as comfortable as they are entertained. This DIY project not only recycles but also enriches your cat's environment, offering endless possibilities for play and exploration.


Crafting with pipe cleaners

Multicolored pipe cleaners - spiral shape

Pipe cleaners are versatile and safe for making cat toys. Twist them into spirals or shapes that bounce unpredictably, captivating your cat's attention. They're lightweight, easy to make, and can provide hours of chasing fun, making them an excellent option for interactive play. The bright colors and erratic movements mimic the erratic actions of prey, keeping your cat engaged and on their toes.


Homemade felt emoji toys

Poop plush toy with smiling and drooling emoji face on white background.

Turn colorful felt into cute, catnip-stuffed emoji toys. They’re not just visually appealing; the scent of catnip makes them irresistible to cats. Easy to make and safe to play with, these toys can help express your creativity while providing your cat with a unique plaything. The soft texture and catnip filling make these toys an instant hit, ensuring they're both cuddled and chased around the house.


Upcycled clothing mice

Handmade knitted toy. Mouse toy in white background . Crochet stuffed animals.

Transform old clothes into adorable mice toys by cutting them into shapes and stuffing them with catnip. These homemade toys are great for cats who love to use their paws and teeth, providing a satisfying catch that’s soft and safe to bite. The scent and texture of the fabric, combined with the enticing smell of catnip, make these mice a realistic and appealing toy for any cat.


Tempting treat puzzles

Clever siamese cat solving pet puzzle to get to the treats.

Create puzzles that challenge your cat to think and move to access treats. Use small boxes with holes or toilet paper rolls pinned together, hiding treats inside. These puzzles stimulate their brains and reward them with treats, making playtime both fun and rewarding. Not only do these puzzles keep your cat's mind sharp, but they also encourage physical activity as they work to solve the puzzle and claim their prize.

Cats aren’t just pets; they’re family members who deserve our time and creativity. Handmade toys offer a unique way to engage with our feline friends, strengthening bonds and ensuring they’re happy, healthy, and active. So, next time you’re about to throw away household items, consider whether they could become your cat’s new favorite toy.



What Is Cushing's Disease in Dogs?

What Is Cushing's Disease in Dogs?

Get your paws on the latest animal news and information